Promoting workplace stair climbing: sometimes, not interfering is the best
نویسندگان
چکیده
BACKGROUND Stair climbing is a vigorous activity and can lead to several health benefits. Studies seeking to increase stair climbing in various public locations have shown positive effects, while results from similar studies conducted in the workplace are inconclusive. This study examined stair climbing in the workplace, and monitored effects from a single- and a combined intervention. Interventions were inspired by nudging, the libertarian method of influencing behavior. METHODS By quasi-experimental design, stair- and elevator traffic in two office buildings was monitored preceding-, during- and following interventions with stair leading footprints alone, and combined with stair-riser banners. Chi square tests were applied to determine differences between baseline and the subsequent periods. Web-based questionnaires were distributed after follow-up period. RESULTS Elevators and stairs were used 45 237 times, of which 89.6% was stair use. Intervention site stair climbing at baseline (79.0%) was significantly reduced with footprints (-5.1%, p < 0.001), and footprints with stair-riser banners (-5.7%, p < 0.001) while baseline stair climbing at the control site (94.2%) remained stable (p > 0.027). CONCLUSIONS Stair climbing was significantly reduced during the intervention periods. Use of stair leading footprints alone, or combined with stair-riser banners in an attempt to influence stair climbing may be ineffective, or cause a negative reaction, when applied in a workplace with a pre-existing high amount of stair climbing.
منابع مشابه
Promoting stair climbing: stair-riser banners are better than posters... sometimes.
OBJECTIVE Stair-riser banners are twice as effective as posters in encouraging stair climbing in shopping centres. This study tested the effectiveness of stair-riser banners in an English train station in 2006-2007. METHOD The train station had a 39-step staircase and an adjacent escalator. Baseline observations (3.5 weeks) were followed by 10.5 weeks of a banner intervention supplemented wit...
متن کاملPromoting stair climbing: effects of message specificity and validation.
Current exercise guidelines encourage the daily accumulation of lifestyle activities, such as stair climbing. Although several studies show that visual prompts can increase stair usage, there has been little systematic assessment of the messages employed. Some of the messages used in previous interventions represent general descriptions of stair climbing (e.g. 'free exercise'), while others emp...
متن کاملPromoting stair climbing in Barcelona: similarities and differences with interventions in English-speaking populations.
This study evaluated the ability of three different messages to encourage stair climbing on the Barcelona underground. Two weeks of baseline were followed by three banner intervention periods with three different messages, each for a 2 week period. Follow-up data was gathered two weeks after removing the messages. Stair climbing increased overall [odds ratio (OR) = 1.45; 95% confidence interval...
متن کاملPromoting routine stair use: evaluating the impact of a stair prompt across buildings.
BACKGROUND Although studies have demonstrated that stair prompts are associated with increased physical activity, many were conducted in low-rise buildings over a period of weeks and did not differentiate between stair climbing and descent. PURPOSE This study evaluated the impact of a prompt across different building types, and on stair climbing versus descent over several months. METHODS I...
متن کاملStair Climbing Intervention with Greater Effects in Overweight Pedestrians
Previous interventions have successfully increased levels of stair climbing in publicaccess settings (e.g. malls). This study used robust methods to establish the magnitude of intervention effects amongst a specific target group – the overweight. Ascending stair/escalator users (N=20,807) were observed in a mall. A two-week baseline was followed by a five-week intervention in which message bann...
متن کامل